PEO vs In-House HRIS: Best HR Strategy for 2025

Running HR across multiple locations isn't just about payroll and compliance. It's about profitability, efficiency, and keeping your team engaged. If you're managing several units, you've probably asked yourself: Should we partner with a PEO or build an In-House HRIS?

Choosing the right HR solution affects your company’s growth, cost structure, and overall success. Let's clearly compare PEO vs In-House HRIS options, focusing on real-world costs, strategic value, and benefits to determine which fits best for multi-unit operators like you in 2025.

First, What Are PEO and In-House HRIS?

Professional Employer Organization (PEO)

Think of a PEO as your outsourced HR partner. They handle payroll, benefits, compliance, risk management, and administrative tasks. Employees become "co-employed," allowing your business to access better benefits and compliance services at scale.

In-House Human Resource Information System (HRIS)

An HRIS is an internal software solution that keeps HR operations under your direct control. You handle payroll, compliance, benefits, and performance management internally, customizing it specifically to your needs.

Understanding the Real Costs (and Savings)

Let's dive deeper into a side-by-side comparison for clarity:

Payroll and Tax Compliance Costs:

• PEO: Covers all payroll, taxes, and compliance. Usually, this costs around 2–12% of payroll.

• In-House HRIS: You maintain control but must cover internal staffing, payroll software, and training. Most HRIS platforms run about $10–$20 per employee monthly ($120–$240 annually), plus staff time for processing and compliance.

  
  

Benefits Administration:

• PEO: Provides high-quality, affordable employee benefits by leveraging economies of scale. Included in the payroll percentage.

• In-House HRIS: Fully customizable but requires internal administration. Costs typically range $200–$400 per employee annually, depending on benefit complexity and state regulations.

Administrative Overhead:

• PEO: Significantly reduces internal HR paperwork and frees staff for strategic work. Included in fees (2–12% of payroll).

• In-House HRIS: Provides full control and customization but adds labor costs for internal HR and payroll staff. Many mid-market businesses spend $500–$1,000 per employee annually once staffing and software costs are included.

  
  

Risk Management and Compliance:

• PEO: Handles safety compliance, workers’ comp, labor laws, and unemployment claims. Included in fees.

• In-House HRIS: You bear direct responsibility for audits, safety, and filings. Typical cost impact runs $200–$500 per employee annually, depending on your state and industry.

  
  

Software Implementation and Maintenance:

• PEO: No upfront software costs (included in service fees).

• In-House HRIS: Implementation can range $10,000–$50,000 for small to mid-sized operators, with annual costs around $75–$150 per employee for licensing and support.

  
  

Employee Self-Service:

• PEO: Robust, ready-to-use online portals included in the price.

• In-House HRIS: Most platforms include self-service portals by default. Maintenance or premium support typically adds $25–$75 per employee annually.

  
  

Scalability and Flexibility:

• PEO: Great for rapidly expanding businesses; limited customization.

• In-House HRIS: Highly customizable but potentially difficult and expensive to scale.

  
  

Financial Comparison: A Multi-Unit Scenario

Let’s break down a realistic 2025 example for clarity.

Scenario: 300 employees across multiple locations

Annual payroll: $15 million (~ $50,000 per employee)

PEO Annual Costs (Estimated)

• Payroll, compliance, and benefits administration (≈ 5 % of payroll): $750,000

• Internal oversight / liaison role: $40,000

Total ≈ $790,000 per year

In-House HRIS Annual Costs (Estimated)

• Payroll & tax administration: $60,000

• Benefits administration: $120,000

• Compliance & risk management: $120,000–$150,000

• HR staff salaries (2–3 team members): $150,000

• Software licensing & maintenance ($75–$150 per employee): $45,000

• Ongoing customization / support / training: $30,000

• General administrative overhead: $100,000–$200,000

Total ≈ $950,000–$1 million per year

For a multi-unit business of this size, a PEO typically delivers annual savings of $150k to $200k compared with maintaining a full in-house HRIS team and infrastructure.

All figures represent 2025 U.S. industry averages for mid-market employers. Actual costs vary by payroll volume, state regulation, and vendor selection.

Beyond Cost: Strategic Factors to Consider:

Money isn't everything. Here’s what else you need to consider:

• Strategic Alignment: HRIS provides deeper internal strategic insights.

• Employee Satisfaction: PEO typically offers competitive benefits, improving retention.

• Compliance and Liability: PEO greatly reduces internal risk.

• Long-Term Scalability: PEOs scale effortlessly, ideal for growth.

  
  

Making Your Decision Clear:

Choose a PEO when:

• Rapid growth or expansion is planned.

• Minimizing internal HR workload.

• Competitive employee benefits are essential.

• Outsourcing compliance and risk makes sense.

Choose an In-House HRIS when:

• Your company requires deep customization.

• Sufficient internal HR resources exist.

• Detailed analytics and strategic HR control are priorities.

• Growth is stable and predictable.

Bottom Line: PEO vs In-House HRIS: Which Wins?

Aspect	PEO	In-House HRIS
Payroll & Taxes	✅ Handled externally by PEO (2–12% payroll)	⚠️ Managed internally (~$200/employee/yr)
Benefits Administration	✅ Access to discounted rates via PEO	⚠️ Internally managed ($300–$500/employee/yr)
Administrative Overhead	✅ Lower (Included in service fee)	⚠️ Higher ($500-$1000/employee/yr)
Risk & Compliance	✅ Outsourced, lower internal liability	⚠️ Internal, higher liability ($200–$500/employee/yr)
Software & Maintenance Costs	✅ Included in PEO fees	⚠️ Initial setup: $10k–$50k+, annual fees: $75–$150/employee
Employee Self-Service	✅ Standard portal included	✅ Included premium support $25–$75 / employee / yr
Scalability	✅ Highly scalable, good for rapid growth	⚠️ Requires significant internal resources to scale
Customization	⚠️ Limited	✅ Fully customizable
Annual Cost (300 employees)	✅ Lower (~$790,000)	⚠️ Higher (~ $950K–$1M)

For most multi-unit operators, especially those experiencing rapid growth, PEO solutions clearly offer significant financial and operational benefits in the short to medium term. Meanwhile, mature businesses needing full customization, extensive analytics, and internal control typically benefit most from an in-house HRIS solution.

Making this decision isn’t just administrative; it's strategic. The right choice positions your business for sustained growth, profitability, and long-term success.

Not sure if a PEO or In-House HRIS is right for your business? Book a free HR Strategy Call with HC-Resource, and we’ll help you make the best decision.

Book a Free Discovery Call with Our Team →